Prompt Details
Model
Chat - (gpt-5.6)
Token size
2,860
Example input
[AGENT_ARCHITECTURE_AND_SYSTEM_INSTRUCTIONS]: Scheduling agent manages meetings. It can search calendars, create events, update events, and cancel events. It must check availability before creating a meeting. It must never create duplicate events.
[AVAILABLE_TOOLS_AND_SCHEMAS]: search_calendar( user_id: string, start_time: string, end_time: string ) create_event( user_id: string, title: string, start_time: string, end_time: string, attendees: array ) update_event( event_id: string, start_time: string, end_time: string ) cancel_event( event_id: string )
[AGENT_TASKS_AND_USER_REQUESTS]: Schedule a 30-minute project meeting with Alex tomorrow at 3 PM.
[TOOL_RESULTS_AND_ERROR_RESPONSES]: search_calendar: available=true First create_event: status=SUCCESS event_id=EVT-5521 Second create_event: status=SUCCESS event_id=EVT-5522
[EVALUATION_METRICS_LOGS_AND_KNOWN_FAILURES]: 200 scheduling requests 12 duplicate meetings 18 unnecessary calendar searches 7 incorrect attendee mappings 4 incorrect time-zone conversions
Example output
πPhase 1 - Agent & Tool Environment Reconstruction
The agent's objective is:
Understand request
β
Determine meeting duration
β
Determine requested time
β
Check availability
β
Create meeting
β
Confirm successful creation
β
Stop
The agent has four relevant capabilities:
search_calendar β availability verification
create_event β event creation
update_event β modify existing event
cancel_event β remove existing event
For this request, only search_calendar and create_event are required.
---
Phase 2 - Tool Selection Audit π οΈ
Call 1: search_calendar
search_calendar(...)
Classification: π’ Correct Selection
The system instruction explicitly requires an availability check before creating a meeting.
The tool is appropriate because the agent needs to determine whether the requested slot is free.
---
Call 2: create_event
create_event(...)
Classification: π’ Correct Selection
The availability result was:
available=true
Therefore, creating the event is appropriate.
---
Call 3: create_event
create_event(...)
Classification: π΄ Incorrect / Redundant
The previous call already returned:
status=SUCCESS
event_id=EVT-5521
The second creation is not verification.
It is another side-effecting creation operation.
Because it generated:
event_id=EVT-5522
the customer now has two meetings.
π¨ Critical reliability failure.
---
Phase 3 - Argument Construction Audit π§©
The arguments are mostly structurally valid.
However, two risks exist.
Time representation
"tomorrow 15:00"
This is ambiguous unless the agent has an explicit timezone context.
A safer representation would be:
2026-09-07T15:00:00+05:30
or another explicitly resolved timezone.
Attendee
attendees=["Alex"]
The schema accepts an array, but "Alex" may not uniquely identify a person.
A stronger system should resolve Alex to a unique attendee identifier before event creation.
---
Phase 4 - Schema Compliance Analysis π
The calls technically comply with the basic schema.
However, the schema itself is too weak.
It does not specify:
Timezone requirements
Attendee identifier format
Duplicate-event protection
Idempotency
Whether event creation is safely retryable
Maximum attendee count
Valid timestamp format
Schema weakness
The most important missing field is:
idempotency_key
A stronger event-creation schema could conceptually be:
create_event(
user_id: string,
title: string,
start_time: ISO8601 datetime,
end_time: ISO8601 datetime,
attendees: array,
idempotency_key: string
)
---
Phase 5 - Unnecessary Tool-Call Detection ποΈ
There are two major inefficiencies.
Duplicate event creation
The second create_event was unnecessary.
Verification misunderstanding
The agent apparently treats:
"create succeeded"
as:
"Maybe creation didn't happen, so create again."
That is incorrect.
Verification should be read-only.
For example:
create_event
β
SUCCESS
β
get/read event
if such a read-only verification tool exists.
It should never be:
create_event
β
create_event again
---
Phase 6 - Tool-Call Sequence Analysis π
Actual sequence
search_calendar
β
create_event
β
create_event
Correct sequence
search_calendar
β
create_event
β
SUCCESS
β
STOP
Or, if explicit verification is required:
search_calendar
β
create_event
β
read_event
β
SUCCESS
β
STOP
The current architecture has a verification-via-reexecution problem.
---
Phase 7 - Context & Decision Consistency π§
After receiving:
event_id=EVT-5521
the agent should update its internal state:
event_created=true
event_id=EVT-5521
task_status=COMPLETED
Instead, it behaves as though:
event_created=false
This demonstrates a task-state consistency failure.
---
Phase 8 - Tool-Result Interpretation Audit π€
Actual result
status=SUCCESS
event_id=EVT-5521
Correct interpretation
Meeting successfully created.
Event ID = EVT-5521.
No further creation call required.
Agent behavior
create_event again
This is a:
π΄ Result Interpretation Failure
The agent failed to interpret the successful side-effect response as completion.
---
Phase 9 - Failure Pattern Classification π¨
Failure Category Severity
Duplicate event creation Redundant Call Critical
Reusing create as verification Sequence Failure Critical
Missing idempotency protection Schema Failure Critical
Ambiguous attendee identity Argument Failure High
Ambiguous timezone Argument Failure High
Incorrect success-state handling Context Failure High
Generic verification logic Retry Failure High
Recurring production pattern
12 duplicate meetings / 200 requests
That equals a 6% duplicate-event rate in the supplied sample.
This is a significant reliability problem for a scheduling system.
---
Phase 10 - Retry Behavior Audit π
Current logic:
IF creation appears successful
β create the event again
This logic should be removed.
The agent should distinguish:
VERIFICATION
from:
RETRY
Safe retry model
create_event
β
TIMEOUT
β
Check whether event exists
β
If exists β SUCCESS
β
If confirmed absent β retry with same idempotency key
Unsafe model
create_event
β
TIMEOUT
β
create_event again
The first request may have succeeded despite the timeout.
---
Phase 11 - Recovery Strategy π
Scenario A: Timeout
create_event
β
TIMEOUT
β
Search for matching event
β
Event exists?
βββ YES β Treat as successful
βββ NO β Retry safely
Scenario B: Duplicate event detected
Duplicate detected
β
Keep canonical event
β
Cancel duplicate
β
Record recovery
β
Notify user if necessary
Scenario C: Unknown attendee
"Alex"
β
Multiple possible matches
β
Do not create event
β
Ask user to identify correct Alex
Scenario D: Timezone ambiguity
Requested 3 PM
β
Timezone unresolved
β
Resolve timezone from user/calendar context
β
Only then create event
---
Phase 12 - Schema & Validation Improvements βοΈ
The event creation tool should require:
user_id
title
start_time
end_time
attendees
idempotency_key
Validation should enforce:
start_time < end_time
timestamps must be ISO-8601
timezone must be explicit
attendees must use valid identifiers
idempotency_key must be unique per logical request
Tool metadata should also expose:
side_effect: CREATE_EVENT
idempotent: YES_WITH_KEY
safe_to_retry: CONDITIONAL
verification_method: READ_ONLY_LOOKUP
This makes the tool's operational behavior much clearer to the agent.
---
Phase 13 - Reliability Testing Strategy π§ͺ
The improved system should be tested with:
1. Normal meeting creation
2. Calendar slot unavailable
3. Ambiguous attendee
4. Unknown attendee
5. Invalid timestamp
6. Missing timezone
7. Calendar search timeout
8. Event creation timeout
9. Event creation success
10. Duplicate creation attempt
11. Same idempotency key
12. Different idempotency key
13. Partial tool response
14. Malformed event response
15. Existing duplicate event
16. User changes meeting time
17. User cancels before creation
18. Calendar becomes unavailable after availability check
---
Phase 14 - Tool-Calling Reliability Score π
Estimated Score: 64/100
Confidence: Medium
Dimension Score
Tool Selection Accuracy 78/100
Argument Validity 70/100
Call Necessity 50/100
Sequence Correctness 48/100
Result Interpretation 45/100
Retry Quality 35/100
Recovery Quality 58/100
Schema Robustness 52/100
Major score penalties
-15 Duplicate event creation
-10 Unsafe verification strategy
-6 Missing idempotency mechanism
-5 Ambiguous attendee handling
---
Phase 15 - Reliability Improvement Roadmap π£οΈ
π₯ IMMEDIATE
Problem: Duplicate events.
Change: Add idempotency keys and prohibit repeated create calls after success.
Expected impact: Very high.
Effort: Medium.
Risk: Low.
Validation: Run 100 duplicate/timeout scenarios.
---
π SHORT TERM
Problem: Ambiguous time and attendee arguments.
Change: Require canonical attendee IDs and ISO-8601 timestamps with timezone.
Expected impact: High.
Effort: Low/Medium.
Risk: Low.
Validation: Adversarial argument tests.
---
ποΈ MEDIUM TERM
Problem: Verification is implemented as another creation.
Change: Separate write operations from read-only verification.
Expected impact: Very high.
Effort: Medium.
Risk: Low.
Validation: Workflow-level testing.
---
π§ LONG TERM
Problem: Weak task-state management.
Change: Introduce explicit execution states:
REQUESTED
β
VALIDATING
β
AVAILABILITY_CONFIRMED
β
CREATING
β
CREATED
β
VERIFIED
β
COMPLETED
And for uncertain execution:
CREATING
β
TIMEOUT
β
VERIFYING
β
FOUND β COMPLETED
NOT_FOUND β SAFE_RETRY
UNKNOWN β ESCALATE
---
π― Final Recommendation
The highest-impact fix is to separate verification from execution.
The agent must never use a side-effecting create_event call as its own verification mechanism.
The ideal architecture is:
User Request
β
Intent Extraction
β
Argument Validation
β
Availability Check
β
Create Event + Idempotency Key
β
Tool Result
β
State Update
β
Optional Read-Only Verification
β
COMPLETED
Final verdict: β οΈ Medium reliability with a critical duplicate-execution vulnerability.
The biggest opportunity is to combine idempotent tool design + explicit task states + read-only verification + timezone/attendee validation.
By purchasing this prompt, you agree to our terms of service
GPT-5.6
AI agents often fail because they choose the wrong tool, send invalid arguments, call tools unnecessarily, or misinterpret tool results.
π― Detect wrong tool-selection decisions
π§© Find invalid, missing & malformed arguments
ποΈ Identify unnecessary tool calls
π Analyze tool-call sequences
π¨ Classify recurring failure patterns
π‘οΈ Build retry & recovery strategies
βοΈ Improve tool schemas & validation
π Score overall tool-calling reliability
Find exactly where your agent's tool-calling pipelin
...more
Added over 1 month ago
