PromptBase
PromptBase SelectGet Select
Close icon
General
Home
Marketplace
Create
Hire
Login
Chat
Sell
Explore

Prompt Details

Model
(claude-5-opus)
Token size
2,512
Example input
[PROJECT_DESCRIPTION]: Purchase and installation of a second CNC machining center to add a night-shift production line [FINANCIAL_INPUTS]: Equipment cost $340K, installation/training $25K, expected to add $180K/year in incremental revenue capacity, payback period estimated at 24 months [APPROVAL_THRESHOLD_CONTEXT]: Purchases over $250K require CFO and CEO sign-off; over $500K requires board approval [ALTERNATIVES_CONSIDERED]: 1) Outsourcing overflow production to a third-party shop at $22/ unit vs. $14/unit in-house, 2) Leasing a used machine at lower upfront cost but higher longterm maintenance risk
Example output
# Capex Approval Memo ## Second CNC Machining Center — Night-Shift Production Line Expansion — $365,000 --- ### CARD 1 — EXECUTIVE SUMMARY This memo evaluates a request to purchase and install a second CNC machining center ($340,000 equipment + $25,000 installation/training = $365,000 total) to enable a new night-shift production line. The stated case projects $180,000/year in incremental revenue capacity and a 24-month payback. This is a **DISCRETIONARY** capacity-expansion investment, not a safety/compliance mandate, so it must clear an ROI bar on its own merits. The decision needed is whether to approve $365,000 in capital spend given that the benefit figure supplied is revenue capacity rather than net profit, with no operating-cost data available to convert it into an actual cash-flow payback. --- ### CARD 2 — FINANCIAL INPUT REGISTER | Line Item | Value | Source Status | Note | |---|---|---|---| | Equipment cost | $340,000 | PROVIDED | Capital equipment purchase price | | Installation/training cost | $25,000 | PROVIDED | One-time setup cost, bundled into the ask alongside equipment | | **Total upfront capital cost** | **$365,000** | PROVIDED | Sum of the two rows above; no recurring/subscription cost identified in the stated inputs (Rule 9 not triggered) | | Incremental revenue capacity | $180,000/year | PROVIDED | Stated as "expected to add" — a forward-looking projection, not a historical actual. This is **revenue**, not net profit — see caveat in Card 3 | | Night-shift operating costs (labor premium, materials, utilities, maintenance) | — | MISSING | Not supplied; required to convert revenue capacity into an actual net cash benefit | | Stated payback period | 24 months | PROVIDED | User-supplied figure; approximately reproducible via cost ÷ revenue (see Card 3) — but see caveat on what that computation actually measures | | Discount rate | — | MISSING | Required for NPV/IRR; cannot be assumed per framework discipline | | Machine useful life / project time horizon | — | MISSING | Not stated; relevant to how long the $180K/year benefit needs to persist to justify the spend | | Annual production volume / unit throughput | — | MISSING | Needed to convert Alternative 1's per-unit cost differential into a total-dollar comparison | --- ### CARD 3 — FINANCIAL CASE | Metric | Value | Computed From | Caveat | |---|---|---|---| | Simple Payback (revenue basis) | ≈24.3 months (2.03 years) | $365,000 (equipment + install) ÷ $180,000/yr revenue | Reproduces the user-stated "24 months" closely. **Critical caveat:** this divides total cost by *revenue*, not net profit. It measures how fast cumulative revenue capacity equals the investment — not how fast actual cash recovers it, since operating costs (MISSING, Card 2) are not netted out. Treat this as a revenue-recovery timeline, not a validated cash payback. | | Simple ROI (revenue basis) | 49.3%/year | $180,000 ÷ $365,000 | Not a true ROI — a true ROI requires net benefit (profit), which requires operating-cost data that is MISSING. This figure should not be read as an approval-grade return metric. | | True Simple ROI (profit basis) | MISSING | — | Cannot be computed without night-shift operating costs | | NPV / IRR | MISSING | — | No discount rate supplied and no explicit multi-year cash-flow schedule (only a single flat annual figure) — per framework Rule 10, this supports only simple payback/ROI, not time-value-adjusted metrics | --- ### CARD 4 — ASSUMPTION FRAGILITY DIAGNOSTIC | Factor | Score | Status | Rationale | |---|---|---|---| | Data Confidence | 3/5 | INFERRED-1 | Equipment and install costs are firm, specific figures (high confidence). The $180K revenue figure is a stated projection with no underlying methodology (no unit price, volume, or market basis disclosed), which tempers overall confidence. | | Sensitivity to Error | 4/5 | INFERRED-2 | The entire benefit case rests on one top-line revenue number with zero cost offset disclosed. Any deviation in that revenue figure — or, more importantly, any real-world operating cost — moves the payback conclusion materially. | | Time Horizon Risk | 3/5 | INFERRED-3 | No stated machine useful life or duration over which the $180K/year is expected to hold. Demand durability and equipment lifespan both introduce risk that a 24-month payback window doesn't capture. | | Assumption Fragility Index (OPERATIONAL EXTENSION — NOT A FINANCIAL METRIC) | HIGH | INFERRED-4 | Synthesized from the three factors above: the headline payback is anchored on a single revenue projection with no operating-cost offset and no stated time horizon. | **Core Fragility Reading:** The hard costs ($365,000) are solid. The benefit side is a single, uncorroborated revenue projection with no cost decomposition — meaning the case's attractiveness rests entirely on an assumption that revenue and net cash benefit are equivalent, which they are not. --- ### CARD 5 — RISK & SENSITIVITY NOTES No values in this input set are formally tagged `ASSUMED` (everything numeric was directly supplied by the requester), so per the framework's discipline, no fabricated stress-test ranges are applied to the $180K figure itself. Two directional risks are worth flagging without inventing numbers: - **If the $180K/year revenue projection undershoots:** the revenue-basis payback lengthens proportionally beyond 24 months. No specific downside percentage is estimated here, since none was supplied. - **If the $180K/year revenue projection overshoots:** payback shortens correspondingly, but this doesn't resolve the underlying structural issue below. - **The dominant risk is not the revenue estimate — it's the missing cost side.** Night-shift production almost always carries a labor premium plus added materials, utilities, and maintenance draw. None of these are quantified. Even a modest operating-cost load against $180K/year could push the *true* cash payback well past 24 months, independent of whether the revenue forecast itself is accurate. --- ### CARD 6 — MUST-HAVE VS. DISCRETIONARY CLASSIFICATION **DISCRETIONARY.** Nothing in the project description references a safety, regulatory, or compliance mandate — this is a capacity-expansion investment intended to generate incremental revenue via a new night shift. As a discretionary spend, it does not get a pass on ROI scrutiny; it needs to clear a return bar on its own numbers. That makes the revenue-vs-profit gap identified in Cards 3–5 directly material to whether this should be approved as currently documented. --- ### CARD 7 — ALTERNATIVES CONSIDERED | Alternative | Cost | Trade-off vs. Proposed | |---|---|---| | Outsource overflow production to a third-party shop | $22/unit (PROVIDED, per-unit only — no volume given, so total dollar cost is MISSING) vs. $14/unit in-house | Avoids the $365,000 capex entirely, but carries an $8/unit premium indefinitely. **Computed breakeven:** $365,000 ÷ $8/unit = 45,625 units — the in-house machine would need to produce roughly that many units over its life to offset outsourcing on unit economics alone. This is derived arithmetically from the two provided figures, not assumed; however, it cannot be converted into a *time-based* breakeven because annual/period volume is MISSING (Card 2). | | Lease a used machine | MISSING (no lease cost figure supplied) | Lower upfront capital outlay reduces initial commitment, but carries "higher long-term maintenance risk" per the input — stated qualitatively only, with no dollar figure for either the lease cost or the maintenance risk. Cannot be numerically compared to the proposed purchase. | --- ### CARD 8 — STRATEGIC ALIGNMENT NOTE **UNKNOWN.** No stated company goal, growth strategy, or capacity target was provided to tie this project to. This is not inferred from general business logic (e.g., "expansion is generally good for growth") per framework discipline — it is left as an open item for the requester to substantiate. --- ### CARD 9 — APPROVAL ROUTING Total ask is $365,000 ($340,000 + $25,000). Per the supplied threshold context — over $250,000 requires CFO and CEO sign-off; over $500,000 requires board approval — this request falls **above the $250K threshold and below the $500K threshold**, and therefore routes to **CFO and CEO sign-off**. Board approval is not required at this dollar level. --- ### CARD 10 — OPEN QUESTIONS FOR FINANCE COMMITTEE - What are the incremental operating costs of running a night shift (labor premium, materials, utilities, maintenance)? Without this, the $180K figure cannot be converted from revenue to net cash benefit. - Is the $180,000/year figure gross revenue or already net of some costs? This needs explicit confirmation. - What discount rate should be applied, if any, for a time-value-adjusted view (NPV/IRR)? - What is the expected useful life of the machine, and over what period is the $180K/year benefit expected to hold? - What is the expected annual/period production volume? This is needed to convert the outsourcing alternative's per-unit differential into a total-dollar comparison and a time-based breakeven. - What is the lease cost and quantified maintenance-risk estimate for the used-machine leasing alternative? - Is there a documented strategic or capacity-planning goal this project supports, or is it purely opportunistic? - Confirm there is no safety/compliance dimension to this request that would change its classification from discretionary. --- ### CARD 11 — METHOD NOTE This memo is a structuring aid intended to organize the supplied inputs into a decision-ready format — it is not a substitute for a financial audit or independent underwriting. It applies the six-part Capital Investment Justification Framework (Cost Structure, Benefit Quantification, Timing & Payback, Risk & Sensitivity, Strategic Alignment, Alternative Comparison), extended with the Assumption Fragility Index (OPERATIONAL EXTENSION — NOT A FINANCIAL METRIC), which flags reliability of the inputs without altering any computed figure. The supplied approval threshold context ($250K / $500K tiers) directly determined the routing conclusion in Card 9, and the two supplied alternatives (outsourcing, used-machine lease) were evaluated as given in Card 7 — no additional alternatives were invented. Before this memo is used for a final decision, a finance professional should validate every line marked `MISSING` above, particularly the night-shift operating-cost data, since that gap is what prevents this from being a verified net-cash payback rather than a revenue-recovery timeline. --- **VERDICT: NEEDS MORE DATA — the $180,000/year figure is incremental revenue capacity, not net profit, and no operating-cost data exists to convert it into an actual cash benefit, so the stated 24-month payback reflects revenue recovery rather than a validated cash payback.**
Claude

Capex Approval Memo Builder

Add to Cart
PromptBase Select
Get this prompt + 9 more with Select$14 your first month, then $19/mo$14 first month, then $19/mo
View Select
Instant accessInstant access
Usage rightsCommercial use
Money-back guaranteeMoney‑back
By purchasing this prompt, you agree to our terms of service
CLAUDE-5-OPUS
Tested icon
Guide icon
4 examples icon
Free credits icon
💰 Feed in a capital-spend proposal and your financial inputs to get a finance-committee-ready approval memo — 11 cards covering payback, ROI, risk & sensitivity, and strategic alignment. Every number is tagged PROVIDED or ASSUMED so nothing sneaks past your committee disguised as a fact, and an "assumption fragility" flag surfaces exactly how shaky the case really is. Handles multi-phase capex and bundled recurring costs correctly instead of blending them into one misleading figure. 📈
...more
Added over 1 month ago
Report
Browse Marketplace