Prompt Details
Model
(claude-5-opus)
Token size
3,372
Example input
[CONTRACT_TEXT]: Excerpt from Section 9 (Limitation of Liability) and Section 12 (Indemnification): each party's aggregate liability is capped at fees paid in the preceding 12 months, except for confidentiality breaches; indemnification is silent on IP infringement claims by the vendor.
[CONTRACT_TYPE]: SaaS Master Service Agreement (MSA), v3, with an attached Data Processing Addendum
[RISK_TOLERANCE]: standard
[COUNTERPARTY_CONTEXT]: We are the smaller party; counterparty is a Series B-funded SaaS vendor with in-house legal counsel
Example output
# Contract Clause Risk Audit
## SaaS Master Service Agreement (MSA) v3 — Counterparty not named (Series B-funded SaaS vendor)
---
### CARD 1 — EXECUTIVE RISK SUMMARY
**Top risk items:**
1. **Indemnification is silent on vendor IP infringement (C2).** Section 12 does not state that the vendor will indemnify the reviewing party against third-party IP infringement claims arising from the vendor's own software/service — a standard SaaS protection that appears absent from the text supplied.
2. **Liability cap carve-out is narrow (C1).** Section 9's cap (12 months' fees) is only pierced for confidentiality breaches — there is no carve-out for IP infringement, data breach/security incidents, or gross negligence, so any claim arising from the C2 gap would likely be squeezed into the same capped bucket as ordinary performance disputes.
3. **Data Processing Addendum content not supplied.** The MSA is described as having an attached DPA, but no DPA text was provided for review, leaving data protection/security terms — a material category for any SaaS agreement — entirely unassessed.
**Recommended immediate action:** Renegotiate Section 12 before signature to add an express vendor IP-infringement indemnification obligation; given the CRITICAL flag on C2, route to counsel review before proceeding regardless of renegotiation outcome.
**Evidence-quality warning:** Only **2 of the 13** clause categories tracked in Card 2 are evidenced by the text supplied (Limitation of Liability, Indemnification). The remaining 11 — including termination, IP ownership, confidentiality survival, governing law, auto-renewal, assignment/change-of-control, force majeure, data protection/security (including the referenced but unsupplied DPA), SLA, insurance, and dispute resolution — are **UNKNOWN**, not confirmed absent from the agreement, simply outside the evidentiary scope of this excerpt. Presence of a clause anywhere in this audit is a text-mapping finding only, never a legal-sufficiency finding.
---
### CARD 2 — CLAUSE COVERAGE MAP
| Clause Category | Status | Location/Excerpt | Risk Tier | Note |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Limitation of Liability | PRESENT | Section 9 — mutual cap at 12 months' fees paid, carve-out for confidentiality breaches | MATERIAL | See C1 |
| Indemnification | AMBIGUOUS | Section 12 — provision exists but is silent on IP infringement claims by vendor | CRITICAL | See C2 |
| Termination (cause/convenience) | UNKNOWN | Not included in text supplied | UNKNOWN | — |
| IP Ownership/Assignment | UNKNOWN | Not included in text supplied | UNKNOWN | — |
| Confidentiality + Survival Period | UNKNOWN | Referenced indirectly via Section 9's carve-out; underlying confidentiality clause and survival term not supplied | UNKNOWN | C1's carve-out depends on this undefined clause |
| Governing Law/Venue | UNKNOWN | Not included in text supplied | UNKNOWN | Needed to resolve Card 10 items |
| Auto-Renewal Notice Window | UNKNOWN | Not included in text supplied | UNKNOWN | — |
| Assignment/Change-of-Control | UNKNOWN | Not included in text supplied | UNKNOWN | Relevant given counterparty is Series B-funded (acquisition risk) |
| Force Majeure | UNKNOWN | Not included in text supplied | UNKNOWN | — |
| Data Protection/Security Terms | UNKNOWN | DPA referenced as attached in contract description; DPA text not supplied | UNKNOWN | Material gap given SaaS data-handling context |
| SLA and Remedies | UNKNOWN | Not included in text supplied | UNKNOWN | — |
| Insurance Requirements | UNKNOWN | Not included in text supplied | UNKNOWN | No insurance cross-reference found in C1 either |
| Dispute Resolution | UNKNOWN | Not included in text supplied | UNKNOWN | — |
---
### CARD 3 — CLAUSE-BY-CLAUSE REGISTER
| ID | Clause Category | Text Excerpt/Locator | Requested/Implied Allocation | Risk Relevance | Status | Risk Tier | Missing Element |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| C1 | Risk-Allocation (Limitation of Liability) | Section 9 — each party's aggregate liability capped at fees paid in the preceding 12 months, except for confidentiality breaches (as summarized in the input; not verbatim contract language) | Liability capped for most claim types; uncapped only for confidentiality breaches | Sets the ceiling on recoverable damages for IP, data, and general performance failures | PRESENT | MATERIAL | No carve-out for IP infringement, data breach, or gross negligence; no insurance cross-reference |
| C2 | Risk-Allocation (Indemnification) | Section 12 — indemnification provision exists but is silent on IP infringement claims by the vendor (as summarized in the input; not verbatim contract language) | Unclear whether vendor bears responsibility for third-party IP infringement claims arising from its own product | Determines who bears the cost/defense of third-party IP suits — a common, material SaaS exposure | AMBIGUOUS | CRITICAL | No stated vendor obligation to indemnify for IP infringement it causes |
---
### CARD 4 — RISK TIER DIAGNOSTIC
#### C1 — Limitation of Liability
| Factor | Score | Status | Rationale |
|---|---|---|---|
| Financial Exposure | 3 | DOCUMENTED | Cap exists at 12 months' fees for most claims, but the single confidentiality-only carve-out leaves exposure effectively unaddressed for other high-impact claim types (see C2 interaction) |
| Operational Constraint | INFERRED-1 | INFERRED | A capped-liability clause on its own typically imposes limited day-to-day operational constraints |
| Legal-Enforceability Uncertainty | INFERRED-2 | INFERRED | Enforceability of liability caps and carve-out scope is jurisdiction-dependent; governing law clause not supplied |
| Counterparty Favorability | 3 | DOCUMENTED | Mutual structure is even-handed on its face, but a narrow carve-out set tends to favor whichever party's typical exposure falls outside it — cannot be fully assessed until C2 is resolved |
| Negotiation Leverage Index (OPERATIONAL EXTENSION — NOT A LEGAL RISK MEASURE) | LOW | INFERRED | Reviewing party is the smaller party facing a funded vendor with in-house counsel; leverage to expand carve-outs is limited absent a specific business justification |
**Core Risk Reading:** The mutual cap structure is a reasonable baseline, but its single narrow carve-out means most non-confidentiality claims — including any IP infringement exposure surfaced by C2 — would fall under the same 12-month cap, which may be inadequate if the C2 gap is confirmed.
#### C2 — Indemnification (IP Infringement Silence)
| Factor | Score | Status | Rationale |
|---|---|---|---|
| Financial Exposure | 4 | DOCUMENTED | Silence on vendor IP-infringement indemnification, combined with C1's cap, leaves the reviewing party's remedy for a vendor-caused IP claim unclear and possibly limited to the general liability cap only |
| Operational Constraint | INFERRED-2 | INFERRED | Absent an express vendor obligation, the reviewing party may need to independently manage or insure against third-party IP claims tied to the vendor's platform |
| Legal-Enforceability Uncertainty | INFERRED-3 | INFERRED | Whether a general indemnification clause is read to implicitly cover IP infringement absent express language varies significantly by jurisdiction |
| Counterparty Favorability | 4 | DOCUMENTED | As written, the gap favors the vendor, who avoids an explicit IP-infringement indemnification obligation |
| Negotiation Leverage Index (OPERATIONAL EXTENSION — NOT A LEGAL RISK MEASURE) | LOW | INFERRED | Same general leverage constraint as C1, though IP indemnification is a standard SaaS customer ask that vendors frequently accommodate even in unequal negotiations |
**Core Risk Reading:** This is the single highest-impact gap in the text supplied — an unaddressed IP-infringement indemnification obligation for a smaller-party customer is a common but serious SaaS contracting risk, warranting CRITICAL tier pending confirmation of the full Section 12 text.
---
### CARD 5 — TOP RISK FLAGS
1. **C2 — CRITICAL:** Indemnification "silent on IP infringement claims by the vendor" — no vendor obligation to indemnify identified in the text supplied.
2. **C1 — MATERIAL:** Liability cap "except for confidentiality breaches" only — no carve-out for IP infringement, data breach, or gross negligence.
3. **Evidence gap — MATERIAL (evidence-quality, not a clause-text finding):** DPA is referenced as attached to the MSA but its text was not supplied, so data protection/security terms cannot be assessed at all.
---
### CARD 6 — REDLINE SUGGESTIONS
| Clause ID | Issue | Redline Confidence | Suggested Direction (non-binding) | Priority |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| C2 | No stated vendor obligation to indemnify for third-party IP infringement claims | INFERRED RISK | Add an express vendor indemnification obligation for third-party IP infringement claims arising from the vendor's software/service, and carve it out from (i.e., uncap it relative to) the general liability cap | HIGH |
| C1 | Liability cap carve-outs limited to confidentiality breaches only | INFERRED RISK / MARKET-STANDARD DEVIATION — NOT VERIFIED FOR THIS JURISDICTION | Consider requesting additional carve-outs (IP infringement indemnification, data breach/security incidents, gross negligence/willful misconduct) | HIGH |
---
### CARD 7 — NEGOTIATION LEVERAGE MAP
*Negotiation Leverage Index (OPERATIONAL EXTENSION — NOT A LEGAL RISK MEASURE)*
| Clause ID | Who Benefits As Written | Market Practice (tagged per Rule 4) | Negotiation Leverage Index | Leverage Note |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| C1 | Roughly mutual as written, though the narrow carve-out set may favor the vendor depending on how C2 resolves | Broader carve-out sets (IP infringement, data breach, gross negligence) are common in SaaS MSAs (MARKET-STANDARD DEVIATION — NOT VERIFIED FOR THIS JURISDICTION) | LOW | Reviewing party is the smaller party against a funded vendor with in-house counsel; leverage is limited absent a specific business justification or competitive alternative |
| C2 | Vendor — absence of an explicit obligation reduces vendor's exposure | Express vendor IP-infringement indemnification is common in SaaS MSAs (MARKET-STANDARD DEVIATION — NOT VERIFIED FOR THIS JURISDICTION) | LOW | Despite limited general leverage, this is a standard, expected customer ask that many vendors accommodate even in an unequal negotiating position |
---
### CARD 8 — INTERNAL CONTRADICTION CHECK
| Clause A | Clause B | Nature of Conflict | Which Should Control |
|---|---|---|---|
| — | — | No contradiction identified within the text supplied | — |
No contradictions were found between C1 and C2 on the evidence available. The text supplied (two clause summaries) is too limited to surface a genuine conflict either within the MSA or against the attached DPA (whose content was not supplied). A fuller document review may reveal a latent conflict — for example, if Section 12 contains an indemnification obligation that is not itself carved out from Section 9's cap — but this cannot be confirmed as `CONTESTED` on the current evidence and is instead logged as an open item in Card 12.
---
### CARD 9 — MISSING-CLAUSE IMPACT ANALYSIS
No clause category in Card 2 carries a confirmed `MISSING` status — the excerpt-only scope of the text supplied means the 11 unevidenced categories are tagged `UNKNOWN`, not `MISSING`, so this card's strict criterion (a confirmed-missing category) is not met by any entry. Two `UNKNOWN` items nonetheless carry enough contextual weight to flag conditionally (`INFERRED`, not asserted as settled):
- **Data Protection/Security Terms (if thin or absent in the full DPA):** In the absence of specific data-breach obligations, the parties would likely fall back to whatever general confidentiality and liability terms exist (i.e., C1's cap), which — given C1's narrow carve-out — could leave a data-breach scenario capped at 12 months' fees, potentially unfavorable to the reviewing party as the data-processing customer.
- **IP Ownership/Assignment (if silent in the full MSA):** Absent explicit IP ownership terms, default commercial practice in SaaS agreements typically leaves each party's pre-existing IP with itself and grants the customer a limited use license — but this is jurisdiction- and fact-specific and should not be assumed to apply here.
---
### CARD 10 — JURISDICTION-SENSITIVITY FLAGS
| Clause ID | Why Jurisdiction-Sensitive | What to Confirm Locally |
|---|---|---|
| C1 | Enforceability of liability caps — and the adequacy of a narrow carve-out set — for negligence or willful-misconduct-adjacent claims varies significantly by jurisdiction | Confirm the governing law clause (not supplied) and whether that jurisdiction limits enforceability of liability caps |
| C2 | Whether a general indemnification clause is construed to implicitly cover IP infringement absent express language is jurisdiction-dependent | Confirm governing law/venue and how courts there construe silence in indemnification provisions |
---
### CARD 11 — VERIFICATION MAP
| Named Standard/Regulation Referenced in Contract | Clause Locator | Verification Status | Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| — | — | NONE NAMED | No named standard or regulation appears in the text supplied |
**NONE NAMED.** The excerpt does not cite any external standard (e.g., ISO 27001, SOC 2, GDPR) directly. The MSA is described as having an attached Data Processing Addendum, which may reference such standards, but that DPA text was not included in this review's evidentiary scope — its applicability is not assumed here.
---
### CARD 12 — OPEN QUESTIONS FOR COUNSEL
- Full text of Section 12 (Indemnification): does it address IP infringement elsewhere, or is the silence complete?
- Full text of Section 9: are there carve-outs beyond confidentiality not captured in the summary supplied?
- Governing law/venue clause, to assess jurisdictional enforceability of the C1 cap and the C2 silence (Card 10).
- Full content of the attached Data Processing Addendum, particularly data-breach liability and its interaction with the Section 9 cap.
- Whether any Section 12 indemnification obligations sit inside or outside the Section 9 liability cap.
- IP ownership/chain-of-title provisions elsewhere in the MSA, not included in the text supplied.
---
### CARD 13 — METHOD NOTE
This audit is a triage aid, not a legal opinion, and does not certify any clause as enforceable, compliant, or safe. Clauses were analyzed per category against the six-category Contract Risk Taxonomy (Risk-Allocation, Term & Exit, IP & Confidentiality, Commercial & Payment, Compliance & Regulatory, Boilerplate/Procedural) rather than by page or section number, with the Negotiation Leverage Index applied only in Card 7 as an operational, non-legal extension. Risk tolerance was specified as `standard`, which shaped ordinary flagging aggressiveness without altering any `PRESENT`/`MISSING`/`AMBIGUOUS` classification or suppressing the C2 `CRITICAL` flag; counterparty context (reviewing party is the smaller party against a funded vendor with in-house counsel) informed Card 7's leverage notes only. The text supplied was a two-clause summary excerpt (Sections 9 and 12) rather than the full MSA and DPA, so this is a narrow-scope audit — 11 of 13 Card 2 categories, and all of Card 11's verification items, remain `UNKNOWN`/`NONE NAMED` pending review of the complete agreement and its DPA. This tool does not replace licensed counsel; signature should not proceed on this analysis alone.
---
**VERDICT: COUNSEL REVIEW REQUIRED — 1 CRITICAL flag (C2: indemnification silent on vendor IP infringement) against only 2 of 13 clause categories evidenced. Adding an express, uncapped vendor IP-infringement indemnification obligation to Section 12 would most change this verdict.**
Get this prompt + 9 more with Select$14 your first month, then $19/mo$14 first month, then $19/mo
View SelectBy purchasing this prompt, you agree to our terms of service
CLAUDE-5-OPUS
⚖️ Paste any contract (NDA, MSA, vendor agreement, employment contract) and get a rigorous 13-card risk audit: clause coverage map, redline suggestions, negotiation leverage, contradiction checks, and jurisdiction-sensitivity flags. Every finding traces to the actual text — no invented "standard" claims. Built for stakeholders deciding whether to sign, renegotiate, or escalate to counsel, before the lawyers get involved. Not legal advice — a pre-counsel triage tool that saves review time. 🔍
...more
Added over 1 month ago
