--- 📊 Original Quality Score: 63% (v-1) — heuristic estimate, not a precise measurement Breakdown: Completeness 18/30, Clarity 14/20, Realism 10/20, Safety 20/20, Specificity 1/10 = 63/100 (50-74% Basic, gaps exist) Requester Profile: Novice — casual, non-technical phrasing with no music-industry terminology. Domain: Song Concept Readiness Check: - Goal: Present (inferred) — "need a song for my wedding video" (personal use inferred from stated occasion) - Expected Output: Missing — "no supporting text found" - Genre/Mood: Partial — "romantic and happy" (mood given, no genre) - Context: Present (inferred) — "for my wedding video" (use context inferred from stated occasion) - Constraints: Missing — "no supporting text found" - Target Use: Present (inferred) — "wedding video" (personal project inferred from stated occasion) 🔒 Safety Review: - Behavior-altering attempt: Missing - PII exposure: Missing - Unflagged IP risk: Missing ⚠️ Risks (ranked by severity): High: Missing length/timing/budget constraints / evidence: "no supporting text found" / impact: musician cannot scope or price the work accurately High: Missing expected output details (vocal vs. instrumental, structure, format) / evidence: "no supporting text found" / impact: production complexity and cost cannot be estimated Medium: No specific genre named, only mood / evidence: "romantic and happy" / impact: risk of stylistic mismatch with client expectations Low: No revision round count specified / evidence: "no supporting text found" / impact: scope creep risk during revisions 💡 Recommendations: 🚨 Critical: (none — no critical-severity gaps found) High: Ask for target song length, deadline, and budget range before quoting High: Clarify whether a vocal track or instrumental is wanted, and desired structure Medium: Ask for a reference genre or example song/artist style (translated to descriptive terms, not the artist's name, if provided) Low: Confirm number of revision rounds included Optimized Request: I'm looking for a romantic and happy song to accompany my wedding video (assumption: personal, non-commercial use, inferred from "wedding video"). I'd like a fully produced vocal track (assumption: vocal was assumed since no instrumental-only preference was stated) with a standard verse-chorus structure lasting roughly 2-3 minutes (assumption: length and structure not specified, so a typical short pop-song format was assumed to suit video pacing). The genre should be warm, light acoustic pop with romantic instrumentation such as acoustic guitar and soft piano (assumption: genre not specified, so a common wedding-video style was assumed). The tempo should be moderate, around 90-110 BPM (assumption: tempo not specified). The lyrics should convey a joyful, romantic story told from a couple's perspective (assumption: narrative perspective inferred from context, not explicitly stated). Please deliver the final track as a high-quality digital audio file suitable for syncing to video (assumption: file format not specified). Budget and number of included revision rounds are still to be discussed (assumption: not specified in the original request). 📊 Improved Quality Score: 73% (v-2) Breakdown: Completeness 18/30, Clarity 20/20, Realism 12/20, Safety 20/20, Specificity 3/10 = 73/100 Score Comparison: Improvement: +10 points — clarity rose to full marks since all ambiguity was resolved via labeled assumptions, and specificity rose slightly from added (assumption-based) concrete details. Completeness stayed flat because assumption-filled fields don't earn genuine completeness credit — only user-supplied or clearly inferred details do. Realism only rose modestly since budget/timeline remain undetermined. Reaching 90%+ requires real answers from the requester, not further assumptions. ℹ️ "This tool audits and improves the wording and completeness of the request — it doesn't verify music-copyright clearance for any genre, era, or sound referenced, or licensing for commercial use; final decisions remain the requester's responsibility. Scores reflect a structured heuristic, not a precise measurement; wording and scores may vary slightly between runs." ❓ A few quick questions that would raise this above 90% — the Optimized Request above is ready to use as-is: ❓ Q1: What's your target length for the song, and do you have a deadline for delivery? ❓ Q2: Do you want a vocal song or instrumental-only track, and is there a specific genre or reference song/style you like? ❓ Q3: What's your budget range, and how many revision rounds would you like included?